How clean REALLY is your indoor air? MailOnline tests the quality in McDonald’s, Wetherspoons and the London Underground – with pollution levels in some places FIVE times higher than outdoor air
If you think of air pollution, it’s likely a vision of smog over a busy city will spring to mind.
But what many people don’t realise is just how bad indoor air pollution can also be.
Studies have shown that indoor air is often five times more contaminated than outside air, with high levels of carbon dioxide (CO2), particulate matter (PM) and volatile organic compounds (VOC).
Whether it’s at home, in the office or simply at the supermarket, many indoor areas are poorly ventilated, allowing toxic air pollution to remain circulating in the air.
Speaking to MailOnline, Stuart Smith, Board Director at ventilation systems company Nuaire said: ‘Most pollutants will be breathed in unconsciously each day without us realising, so it is vital that we raise awareness of the importance of ventilation effectiveness and how we improve indoor air quality within all of our occupied spaces – be it home, work, school or social meeting spaces.’
In time for Clean Air Day (June 16), Nuaire equipped MailOnline’s Shivali Best with a roaming air quality monitor to test levels in a range of popular indoor settings – including Wetherspoons, McDonald’s, and on the London Underground – as well as one busy outdoor location, Piccadilly Circus, for comparison.
MailOnline tested the level of CO2 across six sites – five indoor and one outdoor – and found that levels were the highest in McDonalds and Wetherspoons
In time for Clean Air Day (June 16), Nuaire equipped MailOnline’s Shivali Best with a roaming air quality monitor to test levels in popular indoor settings – including Wetherspoons, McDonald’s, and on the London Underground
Recommended levels for indoor air
These numbers outline recognised benchmarked levels of gasses and particles found in indoor air.
Readings above these would be considered as poor indoor air quality and could have health implications on the people in that space for prolonged periods of time.
CO2 : 400-1,000ppm
Volatile Organic Compound (VOC): 0.5-0.75ppm
Particulate matter (PM) 2.5: 0.15ppm
PM 10: 0.054ppm
- CO2 – 579ppm
- VOCs – 32.4ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.005ppm
- PM 10 – 0.007ppm
The first stop for indoor air quality testing was the MailOnline office in Kensington.
Our office has a large, open-plan design and is set on the third floor of a large, multi-level building.
Thankfully, the levels of CO2 (579ppm), PM 2.5 (0.005ppm) and PM 10 (0.007ppm) were all well within the recommended levels for indoor air.
In fact, the CO2 levels we recorded in the office were the lowest of all indoor sites tested – and half the level of the most polluted indoor areas.
‘The MailOnline office readings suggest ventilation is present within the building, with levels of CO2 showing as low,’ Mr Smith said.
However, the levels of VOCs in the office were 32.4ppm – significantly higher than the recommended 0.5-0.75ppm.
VOCs are emitted as gases from certain solids or liquids and can come from a wide range of products, including cleaning supplies, building materials and furnishings, and office equipment such as copiers and printers.
Meanwhile, these chemicals can also linger in the air from air fresheners, deodorants, hairsprays, aftershaves and perfumes, which could help explain why the levels were high across the indoor settings.
The first stop for indoor air quality testing was the MailOnline office in Kensington. Our office has a large, open-plan design and is set on the third floor of a large, multi-level building
VOCs are emitted as gases from certain solids or liquids and can come from a wide range of products, including cleaning supplies, building materials and furnishings, and office equipment such as copiers and printers. Levels were the highest in Wetherspoons and McDonalds
London Underground (Piccadilly Line)
- CO2 – 835ppm
- VOCs – 17.2ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.115ppm
- PM 10 – 0.234ppm
Having taken our readings in the office, we hopped on the London Underground (Piccadilly Line), which is renowned for its poor ventilation, pollution and bad air quality.
In 2017, researchers from London Metropolitan University tested just how dirty the lines of the London Underground are, with the Victoria Line coming out on top, followed by the Circle Line and Piccadilly Line.
Our tests revealed that CO2 levels here were significantly higher than in the office, clocking in at 835ppm – towards the higher end of the recommended limit.
Having taken our readings in the office, we hopped on the London Underground (Piccadilly Line), which is renowned for its poor ventilation, pollution and bad indoor air quality
Particulate Matter (PM, for short) is a mixture of solid particles and liquid droplets found in the air.
They are created from a variety of sources including traffic, construction sites, unpaved roads, fields, smokestacks or fires.
Most particles form in the atmosphere as a result of reactions of chemicals such as sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides.
Some PM, such as dust, dirt, soot, or smoke, is large or dark enough to be seen with the naked eye.
Other PM is so small it can only be detected using an electron microscope.
PM₂.₅ — with diameters that are generally 2.5 micrometres and smaller — differ from PM₁₀, which have diameters of 10 micrometres or less.
Source: US EPA
PM 2.5 (0.115ppm) and PM 10 (0.234ppm) levels were much higher too, with the PM 2.5 reading the highest on the London Underground out of all the sites tested.
Given the limited ventilation on the London Underground, this is somewhat unsurprising.
‘The major mobile source is road transport, which produces primary particles when fuels are burned or lubricants used up in the engine, when tyres and brakes wear down and from road dust,’ the UK government explained.
‘The main stationary sources are the burning of fuels for industrial, commercial and domestic purposes.’
The level of VOCs (17.2ppm) was also above the recommended level here, although not as high as in the MailOnline office.
- CO2 – 537ppm
- VOCs – 12.8ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.003ppm
- PM 10 – 0.005ppm
Having seen our high recordings on the London Underground, coming above ground was a relief – albeit at the hectic Piccadilly Circus.
The junction has been a very busy traffic interchange since it was constructed back in 1819, and is one of the top tourist destinations in the capital.
For these reasons, we expected the air quality readings to be the highest of all, and were shocked to find that our predictions were very wrong.
Our results revealed that the levels of all four pollutants were the lowest at this site out of all the places tested.
In particular, CO2 levels (537ppm) were very low at Piccadilly Circus, falling at the lower end of the recommended levels.
‘The outdoor location site at Piccadilly Circus falls slightly but still high compared to recommended VOC levels,’ Mr Smith commented.
Having seen our high recordings on the London Underground, coming above ground was a relief – albeit at the hectic Piccadilly Circus. The junction has been a very busy traffic interchange since it was constructed back in 1819, and is one of the top tourist destinations in the capital. For these reasons, we expected the air quality readings to be the highest of all, and were shocked to find that our predictions were very wrong
Particulate Matter (PM, for short) is a mixture of solid particles and liquid droplets found in the air. The levels of PM2.5 – the tiny particles in the air that can cause the air to appear hazy – and PM10 – the particle matter inhalable into the lungs – were highest in McDonalds and the London Underground
What happens if we breathe in CO2?
CO2 can be extremely dangerous at high levels:
Green level (400-1,000ppm)
Typical with a good air exchange
Amber level (1,000-2,000ppm)
Complaints of drowsiness and considered poor air
Red level (2,000-5,000ppm)
Headaches, sleepiness, stagnant and stale, stuffy air, poor concentration, increased heart rate and nausea
- CO2 – 1,329ppm
- VOCs – 58.4ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.111ppm
- PM 10 – 0.243ppm
Things quickly went from good to bad as we headed for a basement table at a busy McDonald’s in the heart of London.
Here, CO2 levels came in at a staggering 1,329ppm – more than twice as high as Piccadilly Circus, and well above recommended levels.
Worryingly, Nuaire says that when CO2 levels are between 1,000-2,000ppm, people can start to feel drowsy.
‘This level of contaminated air presents a higher risk of virus spread and suggests the prominent rebreathing of other people’s breath, due to lowered levels of oxygen in the room,’ Mr Smith explained.
The VOC, PM 2.5 and PM 10 readings weren’t much better, coming in at 58.4ppm, 0.11pppm and 0.243ppm respectively.
- CO2 – 1,191ppm
- VOCs – 99.5ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.008ppm
- PM 10 – 0.011ppm
While many of us enjoy heading to the pub to relax and unwind with friends and family, our pollution readings may put you off.
We sat at the back of The Montagu Pyke, a busy Wetherspoons on Shaftsbury avenue, and were shocked at the air quality levels we recorded.
CO2 levels (1,191ppm) were almost as high as in McDonald’s, and again, surpassed the recommended levels.
Meanwhile, VOC levels (99.5ppm) were the highest in Wetherspoons of all the sites tested, and were more than seven times higher than in Piccadilly Circus.
‘Alarmingly, McDonald’s and Wetherspoons – both popular social eateries – have air quality readings similar to the London Underground tube carriage,’ Mr Smith said.
‘The worst places the MailOnline recorded were public spaces where you would naturally assume ventilation would be taken care of and at its best.’
‘Alarmingly, McDonald’s and Wetherspoons – both popular social eateries – have air quality readings similar to the London Underground tube carriage,’ Mr Smith said
- CO2 – 702ppm
- VOCs – 14.5ppm
- PM 2.5 – 0.010ppm
- PM 10 – 0.011ppm
The final stop on our whistlestop air quality testing tour of London was a Sainsbury’s Local in central London.
Here, we were pleasantly surprised to find that CO2 levels (702ppm) were well within the recommended levels, while VOCs (14.5ppm) were some of the lowest of the places we tested.
And while PM 2.5 (0.010ppm) and PM 10 (0.011ppm) were comparatively low, Mr Smith warned that the levels could still be dangerous.
‘Any level of PM 2.5 or PM 10 is bad and this test identified particulate matter in the air, even within this short monitoring period,’ he said.
‘These tiny particles can be inhaled and transported around the body and get embedded into organs.
‘Just 15 minutes of bad air exposure can stay in the body for over three months and cause bad health conditions from hair loss to heart failure. PM 2.5 alone can shorten life spans.’
The final stop on our whistlestop air quality testing tour of London was a Sainsbury’s Local in central London. While PM 2.5 (0.010ppm) and PM 10 (0.011ppm) were comparitively low, Mr Smith warned that the levels could still be dangerous
What can be done to reduce indoor air pollution?
While most of us are fairly savvy when it comes to outdoor air, Mr Smith admits that there’s a huge amount of confusion when it comes to indoor air.
‘People wrongly assume that because they are inside, away from traffic, the air is clean and safe but it’s really important that we understand, particularly now we’re seeing people spending so much more time indoors, that indoor air is typically around five times worse than outdoor air,’ he said.
‘If we could see how polluted our indoor air is we’d act on it immediately, but the issue is it is invisible and therefore an unknown problem.’
Nuaire’s top tips to improve your indoor air quality
Thankfully, there are several things you can do to improve your indoor air quality:
- Invest in an indoor air quality monitor – being armed with information about the air you breathe is the first step in understanding the best way to tackle the problem
- Refresh the air – as often as possible, open all your windows for as long as is reasonable and let fresh air replace any CO2 build up that’s been circulating in your home. This will also reduce humidity that leads to condensation and mold. If you live on a main road however, try to do this when traffic is low and avoid rush hour
- Be careful what you clean with – bleach and cleaning sprays can hang in the air and give off toxic chemicals, which are really bad for our respiratory health. Switch to organic where you can and avoid candles which can give off high levels of particulate matter
- Check your vacuum – older vacuum cleaners and those that aren’t certified as HEPA may actually be responsible for spraying dust particles into the air, rather than keeping them contained
- Beware of dust build up – dust mites live in the dust in your home and are one of the most common allergens. Refresh bedding frequently and maintain a clean, healthy home to keep them at bay
- Out with the old – modern regulations in furniture manufacturing mean that newly produced furniture gives off less VOCs than older hand-me-downs
- Turn on your extract fans – extract fans can really help pull nasties out of the air in kitchens and bathrooms. Just be sure to check and clean the filters regularly – once a year should keep them in good working order
- Invest in plants – house plants like aloe vera, peace lilies, corn plants and ferns have been proven to reduce NO2 and CO2 in rooms by up to 20 per cent
- Invest in home ventilation – mechanical ventilation and carbon filtration systems can be installed to treat the air throughout the home, and control the pollutants generated. These can cost the same as a premium air purifier but work to clean and filter the air throughout the entire house creating a safe haven for all inhabitants