J.K. Rowling says there are 'innumerable gender identities'

‘There are innumerable gender identities’: JK Rowling is forced to defend herself in new trans row after she hit back at claim on US website that she believes there are only two genders

  • 罗琳, 56, took to Twitter to clarify her views after US article featuring a poll
  • Article reported on poll which claimed 75 per cent of Americans agreed with her
  • Title was ‘Most Americans Agree With J. ķ. 罗琳, There are Only Two Genders
  • Rowling tweeted in response to poll: ‘I’ve never said there are only two genders
  • Harry Potter author J.K. 罗琳 is today at the centre of a fresh trans rights row after clarifying her views on sex and gender, 告诉粉丝: ‘There are innumerable gender identities’.

    The British author, 56, who has previously come under fire for her public views on trans issues, last night tweeted ‘I’ve never said there are only two genders’.

    The comment came in response to a US news website article reporting on a poll claiming that most Americans supported her views on gender.

    But the Gloucestershire-born author, who last month had to call in police after activists posted pictures of her address online, said the question in the poll did not reflect her opinion.

    Responding to the article, titled ‘Most Americans Agree With J. ķ. 罗琳, There are Only Two Genders’, 她写了: ‘Small but important point: I’ve never said there are only two genders. There are innumerable gender identities.

    ‘The question at the heart of this debate is whether sex or gender identity should form the basis of decisions on safeguarding, provision of services, sporting categories and other areas where women and girls currently have legal rights and protections.

    Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling is today at the centre of a fresh trans rights row after clarifying her own views on sex and gender, 告诉粉丝: 'There are innumerable gender identities'

    Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling is today at the centre of a fresh trans rights row after clarifying her own views on sex and gender, 告诉粉丝: ‘There are innumerable gender identities

    ‘Using the words ‘sexand ‘genderinterchangeably obscures the central issue of this debate.

    ‘If you’re interested in what I actually said, see this – (in which I literally say ‘trans lives matterand ‘trans rights are human rights.’).

    Cancelled JK Rowling finally makes appearance in Harry Potter reunion as stars detail ‘the power of her writingalongside archive footage

    Ciara Farmer for MailOnline

    Cancelled JK Rowling is finally set to make an appearance in the Harry Potter reunion with stars seen praising ‘the power of her writingalongside archive footage.

    A teaser for the New Year’s Day special viewed by The Independent, shows Bonnie Wright, who played Ginny Weasley, Daniel Radcliffe, who starred as the titular character and the man behind Hagrid, Robbie Coltrane, discussing the author.

    She is also seen in a segment from 2019 discussing the uphill struggle to find an actor to play Harry when casting the first movie, The Philosopher’s Stone.

    The absence of the Harry Potter creator, 56, comes amid the ongoing row over her views on 变性人 issues and while it was initially believed she would not feature at all, it’s now confirmed she crops up in conversation and archives.

    The eagerly-anticipated reunion sees Daniel join fellow leads Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger, and Rupert Grint, who played Ron Weasley, as well as a slew of fellow co-stars in marking 20 years since the franchise first aired.

    Despite the star-studded turn out, the author behind the stratospherically successful franchise, JK罗琳, was not in attendance at the reunion special.

    The Independent however have now revealed she will be the focus of conversation among the cast as they detail her penmanship.

    邦妮说: ‘So many people were falling in love with JK Rowling’s writing’, while Daniel went on: ”I think it’s very easy to forget that at the time, people were talking about ‘the death of reading.

    Robbie concurred: ‘One of the many reasons I admire JK so much is that millions now read books who would never have lifted a book up in their lives, and you suddenly realise the power of writing.

    在里面 2019 throwback clip meanwhile, JK was seen discussing the struggle of finding a child star to play Harry, 说: ‘We couldn’t find Harry! We just couldn’t find Harry, and it was getting kind of weird, and panicky.

    Detailing her relief at finding Daniel to play the role, she then said: ‘It was very emotional seeing this kid sitting there and talking and I just thought, “是的, that’s him, thank God, we found him”.

    The author will not however appear in any fresh or recent footage.

    广告

    文章, featured on American news site CNS News, reports on a poll by US conservative polling group Rasmussen Reports in which it is claimed that 75 per cent of American adults ‘agree with JK Rowling that there are only two genders’.

    The poll reportedly was carried out via telephone and online, 与 63 per cent said to have ‘strongly agreed’. 总共 18 per cent are reported to have disagreed.

    The article also includes a quote from a piece, penned by Rowling and posted on her website in June last year.

    In the article, which remains on her website, she write: ‘It’s been clear to me for a while that the new trans activism is having (or is likely to have, if all its demands are met) a significant impact on many of the causes I support, because it’s pushing to erode the legal definition of sex and replace it with gender.

    The CNS article, acknowledges that ‘Rowling does not dismiss transgenderism’, but says that ‘she has questioned how, politically, it is eroding the legal definitions of male and female’.

    Rowling’s Twitter response to the article sparked a mixed reaction last night, with some praising her comments, and others criticising.

    One person to reply, Lucie Westenra, 写: '没有, my social legal and medical existence is not a matter of debate, nor is my life the product of some kind of ideology.

    ‘I have an involuntary, lifelong condition, and live in a society that recognises and protects that, which some wish to undermine.

    另一个, Emerald Wilkins, 写: ‘You basically said…I see that there are different gender identities… BUT I don’t think people who identify with them should have legal protections.

    ‘The most pressing point of advocating for trans rights is to ensure legal protection from discrimination. Trans rights now!’

    另一位推特用户写道: ‘I don’t see you as transphobic. What I didn’t like in part was the way you got your point across. With your reach comes a certain responsibility not to step on people’s toes and hurt themunlike in your private life when you talk about it with friends.

    ‘Please don’t get me wrong – 就像你一样 (大概). I think it’s very important to stand up for your opinionseven if many people see it differently.

    ‘That is democracy, that is freedom of opinion. I would have wished only, you would have bought them more often so over, as above.

    另一个添加: ‘I wish both sides of the debate could see the nuance. It makes me sad that people seem to think perspective on this is eitheryou’re with us or aganist us”.

    ‘You be almost entirely with someone but have a caveat or two.

    Though Rowling voice concerns as early as 2018, she became embroiled in the row over trangender rights in June last year after posting tweets which took issue with the phrase ‘people who menstruateused in place of the word ‘women’.

    She later Tweeted: ‘If sex isn’t real, there’s no same-sex attraction. If sex isn’t real, the lived reality of women globally is erased.

    ‘I know and love trans people, but erasing the concept of sex removes the ability of many to meaningfully discuss their lives.

    Rowling’s comments were applauded by some, but heavily criticised by others, who accused the author or transphobia.

    然后, 在九月 2020, she faced renewed calls of transphobia after it was revealed the the villain in her latest book, Troubled Bloodwritten under Rowling’s pseudonym Robert Galbraithis a male serial killer who dresses as a woman to slay his victims.

    She later defended herself against the claims in a passionate essay.

    But she has continued to face criticism, including from stars of the Harry Potter filmswhose careers were built off the back of her best-selling books.

    Harry Potter actors Rupert Grint, 艾玛·沃特森, Daniel Radcliffe and Eddie Redmayne have previously criticised the author for her remarks.

    Actor Chris Rankin this week became the franchise’s latest star to slam her views, by branding them as ‘damaging’.

    演员, who played Percy Weasley in six of the eight films about the boy wizard, 说过: ‘I do a lot of work with charities that are LGBTQ+ focused.

    ‘A lot of my family are members of the community. You can probably guess where my allegiances lie in that respect.

    与此同时, debate erupted about whether or not Rowling would appear in the upcoming Harry Potter reunion.

    Earlier this week it was revealed that, in clips of the New Year’s Day special, stars had praised ‘the power of her writingand that she would appear in archive footage.

    She is also seen in a segment from 2019 discussing the uphill struggle to find an actor to play Harry when casting the first movie, The Philosopher’s Stone.

    The eagerly-anticipated reunion sees Daniel join fellow leads Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger, and Rupert Grint, who played Ron Weasley, as well as a slew of fellow co-stars in marking 20 years since the franchise first aired.

    那是当时: JK is pictured with Rupert and Danielle at the Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone in 2001

    那是当时: JK is pictured with Rupert and Danielle at the Harry Potter And The Philosopher’s Stone in 2001

    打开: A teaser for the New Year's Day special, shows Bonnie Wright, (最右边) who played Ginny Weasley. Daniel Radcliffe, (中央) who starred as the titular character and the man behind Hagrid, Robbie Coltrane, discussing the author

    打开: A teaser for the New Year’s Day special, shows Bonnie Wright, (最右边) who played Ginny Weasley. Daniel Radcliffe, (中央) who starred as the titular character and the man behind Hagrid, Robbie Coltrane, discussing the author








    Despite the star-studded turn out, the author behind the stratospherically successful franchise, JK罗琳, was not in attendance at the reunion specialsparking outrage from some fans who accused makers of attempting to erase her from the franchise over her views.

    Last month it was revealed that Rowling had reported three trans activists to the police after they published a photograph of her Edinburgh address on social media.

    Police Scotland said they had been made aware and inquiries were ongoing, while the group had since deleted the social media post.

    It came as two US Quidditch leagues announced last month their plans to change their names in order to ‘distancethemselves from Rowling over her views.

    US Quidditch (南昆士兰大学) 和大联盟魁地奇 (MLQ) said they would decide on new names for the game, which Rowling dreamed up as part of her Harry Potter books.

    系列中, the sport is played by wizards on flying broomsticks, while the real-life version is a contact sport, played by more than 450 teams in over 30 国家.

    评论被关闭.