Hi ho, hi ho, it’s off to woke we go! Paralympic swimmer Will Perry who has dwarfism defends Snow White remake and says ‘we shouldn’t cancel a fairy tale that’s so loved’ – after Peter Dinklage attacked it
A Paralympic swimmer who has a common form of dwarfism called achondroplasia has defended Disney’s remake of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs – after Peter Dinklage blasted it as ‘backward’.
Will Perry, 21, from Northamptonshire, に登場 ITVの おはようイギリス today to discuss whether the studio’s live-action production – which is in its third year of development – should be cancelled to avoid reinforcing stereotypes.
ゲーム・オブ・スローンズ star Dinklage criticised Disney for remaking the 1937 映画 – which sees the comic dwarf characters living in a cave together – questioning: ‘Have I done nothing to advance the cause from my soap box? I guess I’m not loud enough.’
に応じて, the American company said it is ‘taking a different approach’ with Snow White’s seven companions and has been consulting with members of the dwarfism community throughout the early stages of production.
Will said he welcomes Disney’s consultation, and admitted certain aspects of the film, such as its name and the little people’s home could be tweaked, but insisted the ‘much loved fairy tale’ shouldn’t be ‘cancelled’.
A Paralympic swimmer (左の写真) who has a common form of dwarfism called achondroplasia has defended Disney’s remake of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs – after Peter Dinklage (右の写真) blasted it as ‘backward’
Will Perry, 21, from Northamptonshire, appeared on ITV’s Good Morning Britain today to discuss whether the studio’s live-action production – which is in its third year of development – should be cancelled to avoid reinforcing stereotypes. 写真, インクルード 1937 Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
He appeared on GMB alongside Fats Timbo, a TikTok sensation, comedian and model, who was born with dwarfism but prefers the term ‘little people’.
She said even the title ‘isn’t appropriate at all’, adding ‘dwarfs, the name dwarf, is a medical term, and it’s called a mythical creature. So people don’t know how to differentiate either one.’
しかしながら, 意志, who represented Great Britain at the last Paralympic Games, said he was ‘strongly against cancel culture and wokeism’.
彼は言った: ‘I welcome Disney’s choice to consult people but why didn’t they do that at the start, because I’ve read all sorts of things about when they create different movies, they’ve consulted people of different cultures and different races, down to the smallest detail.
But if they’re going to, then fantastic. I don’t think we should cancel a fairy tale that’s so loved, so many people… love the story, and innocently as well.
‘I don’t think it should be cancelled, it’s brilliant to have a little look and say “OK let’s consult people with dwarfism, get their opinion, we might have to make some tweaks” but I don’t think it should be cancelled at all.
Peter Dinklage (左) expressed his displeasure towards Disney for remaking their 1937 animated classic Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. He slammed Disney for remaking the ‘backward’ film and applauding the casting of West Side Story breakout star Rachel Zegler (正しい) as Snow White
Will appeared on GMB alongside Fats Timbo (一緒に描かれています), a TikTok sensation, comedian and model, who was born with dwarfism but prefers the term ‘little people’
TikTokスター (写真) said even the title ‘isn’t appropriate at all’, adding ‘dwarfs, the name dwarf, is a medical term, and it’s called a mythical creature. So people don’t know how to differentiate either one.’
‘Even if it’s just adjusting the name slightly, or we’re not in a cave, we’re in a house, we’re not depicted as mindless stupid characters, we’re sentient beings, we have feelings, we have opinions.’
Fats suggested the lack of storylines for the seven dwarfs in the original animation was a ‘bit weird’.
‘As soon as they see a little person, they think we’re a mythical creature, they think that we don’t have a personality,’ 彼女は言いました.
‘And the thing is with Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, they’re just catering to Snow White and they don’t have their own stories and it’s a bit weird, seven dwarfs living in a cave.
Will added: 'もちろん, we’re all about positive role models and positive images, and as much as Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is a loved and very well known fairy tale it can lead to obviously misconceptions for people with dwarfism.
Diseny said it is ‘taking a different approach’ with Snow White’s seven companions (pictured in the original) and has been consulting with members of the dwarfism community throughout the early stages of production
‘….Midget is incredibly offensive, it’s the n-word for people with dwarfism, it’s really bad, so even though it doesn’t sound as mythical, Snow White and the Seven Little People, it produces a more realistic image of people with dwarfism to the kids who read and watch and love the fairy tale that is Snow White.’
How Disney’s classic cartoons became ‘sensitive viewing’
Disney in 2020 began slapping racism warnings on some of its most iconic movies, 会社の白雪姫の発表を受けて, to alert viewers to sensitive scenes.
The media conglomerate believes some of its older cartoons contain outdated racial or ethnic stereotypes, and now opens some films with a disclaimer.
読む: ‘This program includes negative depictions and/or mistreatment of people or cultures.’
Movies with warning include the 1970 会社の白雪姫の発表を受けて, 1955 犬のラブストーリーレディとトランプと 1960 会社の白雪姫の発表を受けて.
アリストキャッツに関連して, Disney warns viewers about a scene where one cat, voiced by a white actor, yells out stereotypical Chinese ‘words’ 箸でピアノを弾きながら.
Peter Pan viewers are warned that Native Americans Indians are referred to as ‘redskins’. Disney says scenes in which Peter and The Lost Boys dance in native American headdresses are a ‘form of mockery and appropriation of Native peoples’ culture and imagery.’
The Jungle Book has also been highlighted, つまり、猿王ルイの描写のために, which was accused of perpetuating a stereotype of African Americans.
他の場所 1941 release Dumbo comes under fire for its references to racist segregationist laws in the deep south, as well as its use of affected African-American voices.
The lead crow in the film is also called Jim Crow – a reference to the segregation laws in late 19th and early 20th Century America.
Lady And The Tramp has been placed on the list due to its perceived stereotyping of Asians courtesy of Siamese cats Si and Am, while a dog pound features canines with largely ethnic names and accents
The paralympian added that little people in films are either ‘too mythical or presented in a comical fashion’.
'例えば, in Wolf of Wall Street, where we’re used as darts, we’re used as projectiles, we’re not even portrayed as living things,’ 彼は言った.
‘Then you’ve got Oompa Loompas in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, we’re only really presented to the public and society, as comical characters.’
Fats added: ‘Ever since I was growing up, people would say to me, you’re one of the Snow White of the Seven Dwarfs, or an Oompa Loompa, or some people would try and pick me up because they think i’m an object to throw about because of what they’ve seen in the media.
‘A lot of little people have had similar things. That’s why I think it’s so important to have more positive representation for little people.’
A Disney spokesperson said in a statement to the Hollywood Reporter 火曜日に: ‘To avoid reinforcing stereotypes from the original animated film, we are taking a different approach with these seven characters and have been consulting with members of the dwarfism community.
‘We look forward to sharing more as the film heads into production after a lengthy development period.’
The response came after Dinklage blasted Disney for remaking the 1937 film and shared he was surprised by the casting of West Side Story breakout star Rachel Zegler as Snow White.
‘Literally no offence to anyone, but I was a little taken aback when they were very proud to cast a Latina actress as Snow White — but you’re still telling the story of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs,’ Drinklage, 52, told Marc Maron on his WTF ポッドキャスト.
‘Take a step back and look at what you’re doing there. It makes no sense to me. You’re progressive in one way and you’re still making that f***ing backward story about seven dwarfs living in a cave together, what the f*** are you doing man?’
Disney said the film, which is still years from release, will have cultural consultants, just like its life-action remakes of Aladdin and Mulan did.
The studio also claims it has been working on reimagining the dwarf characters since its earliest production stages.
Disney did not immediately respond to DailyMail.com’s request for comment.
‘Have I done nothing to advance the cause from my soap box? I guess I’m not loud enough,’ Dinklage questioned.
He added he didn’t know what studio was remaking Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, but he recalled, ‘they were so proud of it.’
‘All love and respect to the actress and all the people who thought they were doing the right thing. But I’m just like, 何してるの?’ 彼が追加した.
Will said he welcomes Disney’s consultation, and admitted certain aspects of the film (写真), such as its name and the little people’s home could be tweaked, but insisted the ‘much loved fairy tale’ shouldn’t be ‘cancelled’.
Dinklage has a form of dwarfism known as achondroplasia, which affects bone growth, causing him to have shorter limbs.
He said the story of Snow White can still be told, but it needs to be updated to reflect today’s standards.
‘If you tell the story of “Snow White” with the most f***ed up, progressive spin on it? テレビで放映された戴冠式のアイデア. オールイン,’ 彼は言いました.
WHAT IS DWARFISM?
Dwarfism is general term used to cover a swath of conditions that result in the medical term of restricted growth.
There are two main types of restricted growth:
Achondroplasia is a DSS type of dwarfism and is the most common cause of the condition.
As well as having short stature, some people with restricted growth also have other physical problems, such as bowed legs or an unusually curved spine.
しかしながら, most people don’t have any other serious problems. They can often live a relatively normal life and have a normal life expectancy.
The original animated film was based on an 1812 fairy tale from The Brothers Grimm, though the dwarfs in that story lived in a cottage, not a cave.
Dinklage’s concerns were shared by some charities, including the Restricted Growth Association in the UK.
‘I very much stand with Peter Dinklage on the disappointment and irritation towards Disney for the remake of Snow White,’ Rhonda Cutmore, a member of the association, 言った 電信. ‘As a 46-year-old woman with restricted growth, this story has always had a negative impact on me. Not just the physical characteristics, but the labelling of “Dopey” そして “Bashful”, were not helpful in the playground.
彼女は付け加えた: ‘People with restricted growth are in majority born to average height parents – they never live in gingerbread houses, have little bear beds nor live in homogeneous groups together.’
Dwarfism writer Steph Robson said she hoped film producers make an effort to avoid stereotypes in its retelling of the classic movie.
‘It is my hope that the latest live action remake, ハリーポッターに会うウクライナの孤児たちの興奮, 意志, at the very least go some way to redress the decades of the one-dimensional stereotypes that our disability continues to experience, especially within arts and cultural settings,’ 彼女はアウトレットに言った.
The story has also been criticised as being ableist for portraying the dwarfs with lesser intelligence and Snow White seeing them as children.
Zegler will star alongside Gal Gadot as the Evil Queen with Marc Webb directing from a script by Greta Gerwig and Erin Cressida Wilson.
Oscar-nominated producer Marc Platt, who also worked on Disney’s live-action rendition of The Little Mermaid, is set to produce the film.
その間, Dinklage will next be seen in American Dreamer with Shirley MacLaine, Danny Glover, Matt Dillon and Danny Pudi, 画面上でのキャリアを追求する.
He has a number of projects currently filming like Hitpig, The Toxic Avenger and Brothers.